Ontario’s top court heard an appeal Friday by the legal team behind the $10-billion Robinson Huron Treaty settlement — challenging a judge’s decision to slash their legal fees by nearly half a billion dollars.
“This court may never hear an appeal like this one again,” Brian Gover, counsel for Nahwegahbow Corbiere Genoodmagejig, the law firm appealing the decision, told a three-judge panel in his opening remarks.
“The application judge began from his visceral reaction to the size of the fee and worked backward to his conclusion that the legal team should not receive it.”
The originial case was tied to retroactive payments owed to the 21 Robinson Huron Treaty First Nations for access to natural resources in their traditional territory — about 92,000 square kilometres to the north and east of Lake Huron.
There are about 15,000 Anishinaabek living in Robinson Superior treaty territory, and 35,000 Robinson Huron treaty beneficiaries. (Library and Archives Canada)
Under the terms of the treaty, annual payments to First Nation members were set at $4 per person in 1874, despite a promise that the annuity would increase as the value of the land’s resources grew.
Counsel argues legal team shouldered heavy risk
It took more than a decade of litigation to secure the historic $10-billion settlement.
To finance the case, the Robinson Huron Treaty Litigation Fund entered into a partial contingency fee agreement with Nahwegahbow Corbiere Genoodmagejig in 2011. The lawyers agreed to reduce their hourly rates in exchange for five per cent of any successful settlement outcome.
Atikameksheng Anishnawbek and Garden River First Nation challenged the original $510-million legal bill in May 2024. Both communities are part of 21 First Nations involved in the landmark annuities case.
Last October, Ontario Superior Court Justice Fred Myers ordered the team’s $510-million legal bill reduced to $23 million.
The appeal is being heard by a three-judge panel at the Court of Appeal for Ontario, composed of justices Julie Thorburn, Renee Pomerance and Jill Copeland.
Gover argues that Myers incorrectly treated the case as an “ordinary case,” losing sight of the unique and complex legal services that Nahwegahbow Corbiere Genoodmagejig provided.
But Thorburn pushed back during exchanges with Gover, noting that the lower court judge took no issue with the results achieved or the legal complexity of the case. Instead, the judge’s concern centered on the value to the clients.
Gover responded that the judge failed to look at the matter holistically, suggesting he should have considered the financial risk and what a loss would have meant for the clients.
Nahwegahbow Corbiere Genoodmagejig “bore a significant burden here that they carried for 17 years. The weight of not letting their communities down. This is a burden few counsel will ever bear,” he said.
“Failure would not have been left in the courtroom. It would have followed them home.”

Atikameksheng Anishnawbek is one of two 21 First Nations to challenge the legal fee. (Aya Dufour/CBC)
Gover also argued that the case helped reset the treaty relationship between the First Nations and the Crown, with benefits that will extend across generations.
“My point is that no hourly rate, no multiplier and no percentage can capture that. That is of immeasurable value,” he said.
First Nations felt they could not assess fees
Gover also took issue with Myers’ suggestion that the First Nations who retained the firm were “naive and ill-informed,” arguing that the conclusion echoed centuries of paternalistic attitudes toward Indigenous peoples.
In his ruling, Myers criticized the lawyers for bringing their personal interests and the 21 First Nations ’ interests into conflict by charging the high fee, discouraging the First Nations from getting outside legal advice on their fee, and pressuring them to approve it.
“The chiefs negotiated a request for 15 per cent down to five per cent and thought they had done rather well,” Myers wrote.
Gover argued that this assessment failed to recognize the First Nations’ ability to negotiate a complex legal agreement.
“We would not even be having this conversation if the client consisted of 21 municipalities,” he told the panel.
He also pointed out that opposing counsel had not presented evidence of what independent legal advice the First Nations would have received about the agreement when it was negotiated in 2011.
Lawyers representing the estate of the late senior litigator Joseph Arvay, a member of the Robinson Huron Treaty Litigation Fund, also spoke in support of the appeal. They adopted Gover’s arguments and requested that — if the original agreement is not enforced — the legal team’s fee be set at no less than $130 million based on the reasonable value of their work.
That amount on a $10 billion recovery would represent a 1.3 per cent fee, noted Michael Eizenga.
“But 1.3 per cent or even double that would be historically low,” he said.
The appeal is now before the judges, who will consider whether the lower court judge was justified in reducing the legal team’s fees by nearly half a billion dollars.
Michael Rosenberg, counsel representing Atikameksheng Anishnawbek and Garden River First Nation, is arguing that the appallents aren’t able to prove that Myers made a legal error in his judgement and the case should be dismissed.
He said that because of cultural practices — and because the contingency fee based on a per cent of the winnings was consecrated in a pipe ceremony — the First Nations felt they could not assess the fees in an honourable way.

Atikameksheng Anishnawbek Gimaa (Chief) Craig Nootchtai, far left, and Garden River First Nation Ogimaa Kwe (Chief) Karen Bell, right, raised the case on if the $510-million payment to lawyers who litigated the Robinson Huron treaty Fund was reasonable. (Alex Flood/CBC)
“It’s one thing to want the lawyers to shoulder risk, it’s another thing to agree to a bargain that is unfair,” Rosenberg told the judges.
“[The fee] cannot be reasonable when measured today in the face of a $10 billion settlement. In particular, one in which the lawyers would receive more than 15 of the 21 First Nations.”
Rosenberg also pointed to the fact that the original legal team had threatened to quit when they were pushed back on the legal fees.
“You have this difficult dynamic where you have a client that feels as though it has to get to an agreement. You have lawyers who are threatened to quit if they don’t get more. And that’s precisely the circumstances in which independent legal advice would have been helpful,” he said.
The judges have reserved their decision.

