Listen to this article
Estimated 3 minutes
The audio version of this article is generated by AI-based technology. Mispronunciations can occur. We are working with our partners to continually review and improve the results.
New Democrats are accusing the Liberals of taking a colonial approach to their major projects legislation.
Five days into committee meetings on Bill C-39, the Building Canada Strong Act, the Liberal majority rejected all but a few of the opposition’s proposals to strengthen references in the bill to Indigenous rights, the constitutional duty to consult and free prior and informed consent.
Frustration at the failed New Democrat amendments reached a boiling point when NDP MP Leah Gazan broke down in tears.
Gazan, who is a member of Wood Mountain Lakota First Nation, also took issue with the points of order Liberals raised about the relevance of her line of questioning.
“I find as a rights holder it disgusting when an Indigenous person in this committee asks about environmental protections, and what the definition is, that I am deemed out of order,” Gazan said on Thursday night.
A civil servant testifying during the parliamentarian’s remarks also became emotional and asked for the proceeding to be suspended.
Liberals on the committee say Gazan’s amendments are duplicative, reflecting clauses that are already in the bill or existing federal legislation.
Federal laws “already reference the UNDRIP [United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples]” said Liberal MP Parm Bains.
He added the government’s constitutional duty to consult continues to apply regardless of whether the NDP’s amendments are adopted.
Over the past week, government officials appearing at committee said Bill C-39 does not rush consultation with Indigenous nations.
Although the government wants decisions on mines, pipelines and power lines to be completed within one year, it expects that consultation with affected communities would begin long before a project gets to the regulator.
The act creates what the government calls a “Crown Consultation Hub” to co-ordinate the federal government’s constitutional obligations to Indigenous nations.
The bill also contains provisions to extend the approval timeline to complete consultation.
Day of action planned
Gazan appeared Thursday at a news conference with First Nations youth from Attawapiskat, a Cree First Nation in northern Ontario.
“We have a constitutional duty to uphold the rule of law, something that is not happening in this committee,” Gazan said.
She said this is a “slap in the face” to democracy, Canada, “Indigenous Peoples, workers and a livable planet.”
The young men who appeared with her from Attawapiskat are Ramon Kataquapit — founder of Okiniwak Youth Movement — and Jeronimo Kataquapit of Here We Stand. Both announced a day of action on Parliament Hill on Dec. 8.
Hundreds of chiefs from across the country are expected to gather in Ottawa for an Assembly of First Nations meeting the same day.
The Kataquapits are vehemently opposed to development of the Ring of Fire, a mineral-rich region in northern Ontario.
“You can’t fast-track nation building,” said Kataquapit. “Bill C-39 is not only a direct attack on Indigenous rights, but is a direct attack on democracy itself, because this not only affects Indigenous people, but it affects Canadians all over the country.”
Thursday night was not the first time tempers ran high at the special committee studying Bill C-39.
Earlier Thursday, the House of Commons committee briefly went off the rails as MPs argued about weekend sittings.



